Root Framework Comparison 2025

Comprehensive analysis of Magisk, KernelSU, and APatch to help you choose the right root solution for your Android device.

Quick Navigation

• Quick Comparison
• Framework Analysis
• Device Recommendations
• Technical Deep Dive
• Migration Guide
• Decision Framework

Related Guides:

• Main Rooting Guide
• Magisk Installation
• KernelSU Installation
• APatch Installation

---

Quick Comparison

Aspect	Magisk	KernelSU	APatch
Target Users	Most users	Advanced users	Alternative seekers
Setup Difficulty	Easy	Moderate	Moderate
Android Support	6.0-15	11+ (GKI 2.0+)	10+
Kernel Requirements	Stock/Custom	Custom with KSU	Stock/Custom
Root Hiding	Good (DenyList)	Excellent	Good
Community Size	Largest	Growing rapidly	Small
Development Status	Community maintained	Very active	Active
OTA Updates	Manual re-patch	Sometimes survives	Manual re-patch
Best Feature	Ecosystem	Security	Compatibility

Quick Decision Matrix

Choose Framework	When You Need
Magisk	• First-time rooting • Maximum module support • Wide device compatibility • Established solutions
KernelSU	• Enhanced security • Better root hiding • Custom ROM usage • Kernel-level control
APatch	• Magisk failures • Alternative approach • Specific device issues • Experimental features

---

Framework Analysis

Magisk

The Industry Standard

Architecture: Boot image modification with systemless implementation via Zygisk

Strengths:

• Largest module ecosystem with 1000+ modules
• Extensive documentation and community support
• Universal device compatibility
• User-friendly interface and management
• Mature, stable codebase

Limitations:

• Community-maintained (original developer inactive)
• Requires boot image re-patching after OTA
• Increasing Play Integrity detection challenges

Installation: 📖 Magisk Guide

---

KernelSU

Kernel-Level Root Solution

Architecture: Direct kernel integration providing root at the lowest system level

Strengths:

• Superior security through kernel isolation
• Better performance (kernel-space operations)
• Module signature verification
• Survives some OTA updates
• Advanced app profile system
• Most effective root hiding

Limitations:

• Requires custom kernel support
• Limited device/kernel availability
• ~80% Magisk module compatibility
• More complex initial setup

Installation: 📖 KernelSU Guide

---

APatch

Alternative Patching Method

Architecture: Hybrid kernel patching combining Magisk and KernelSU approaches

Strengths:

• Works where Magisk fails
• Handles complex firmware scenarios
• Alternative injection methods
• Growing device support

Limitations:

• Smallest module ecosystem
• Limited documentation
• Less mature codebase
• Smaller community

Installation: 📖 APatch Guide

---

Device Recommendations

Major Manufacturers

Brand	Primary Choice	Alternative	Critical Notes
Google Pixel	Magisk	KernelSU¹	Best overall support
Samsung Galaxy	Magisk	APatch²	⚠️ Knox trips permanently
Xiaomi/Redmi/POCO	Magisk³	KernelSU⁴	ROM-dependent
OnePlus	Magisk	KernelSU	Both work excellently
Nothing Phone	Magisk	KernelSU	Active development
Motorola	Magisk	APatch	Straightforward process
ASUS ROG/Zenfone	Magisk	KernelSU	Gaming optimizations available
Realme/OPPO	Magisk	APatch	Region-specific quirks

¹ Requires custom kernel
² For problematic devices
³ Stock MIUI/HyperOS
⁴ Custom ROMs preferred

SAMSUNG KNOX

Bootloader unlock permanently trips Knox eFuse, disabling Samsung Pay, Secure Folder, and Samsung Pass forever - regardless of root method.

---

Technical Deep Dive

Security Architecture

Security Feature	Magisk	KernelSU	APatch
Permission Model	App-based	Profile-based	App-based
UID Isolation	Limited	Strong	Limited
Namespace Isolation	No	Yes	No
Module Verification	Basic	Signature-based	Basic
Root Access Control	Standard	Advanced	Standard

Module Ecosystem

Metric	Magisk	KernelSU	APatch
Available Modules	1000+	300+	50+
Cross-Compatibility	Native	~80% Magisk	~60% Magisk
Popular Modules	All available	Most work	Limited selection
Update Frequency	Regular	Active	Varies

Root Detection Evasion

Detection Method	Magisk	KernelSU	APatch
Basic Integrity	Pass⁵	Pass⁵	Pass⁵
Device Integrity	Difficult	Difficult	Difficult
Strong Integrity	Very rare	Very rare	Very rare
Banking Apps	Variable	Better	Variable
Gaming Anti-Cheat	Hit/miss	Better	Hit/miss

⁵ Requires additional modules (Shamiko, SUSFS, Tricky Store)

---

Migration Guide

Pre-Migration Checklist

• [ ] Full device backup created
• [ ] Module list documented
• [ ] Stock boot image available
• [ ] Recovery access confirmed
• [ ] Critical apps tested

Migration Paths

Magisk → KernelSU (1-2 hours)

1. Backup & Document

   adb backup -apk -shared -all -system

2. Uninstall Magisk completely
3. Flash KernelSU-enabled kernel
4. Install KernelSU Manager
5. Reinstall compatible modules
6. Configure app profiles

Magisk → APatch (30-60 minutes)

1. Create full backup
2. Uninstall Magisk
3. Flash APatch boot image
4. Install APatch Manager
5. Verify root access
6. Install essential modules

KernelSU → Magisk (30-60 minutes)

1. Document KernelSU modules
2. Flash stock/ROM boot image
3. Patch with Magisk
4. Flash patched boot
5. Reinstall modules from Magisk repo

---

Decision Framework

graph TD
    A[Start] --> B{First time rooting?}
    B -->|Yes| C[MAGISK]
    B -->|No| D{Need max modules?}
    D -->|Yes| C
    D -->|No| E{Custom kernel available?}
    E -->|Yes| F{Priority: Security/Hiding?}
    F -->|Yes| G[KERNELSU]
    F -->|No| C
    E -->|No| H{Magisk working?}
    H -->|Yes| C
    H -->|No| I[APATCH]

Use Case Scenarios

Scenario	Recommended	Reason
Daily Driver Phone	Magisk	Stability & support
Gaming Device	KernelSU	Better anti-cheat evasion
Development/Testing	KernelSU	Advanced features
Banking Phone	KernelSU	Superior hiding
Problematic Device	APatch	Alternative approach
Learning Rooting	Magisk	Best documentation

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Essential FAQs

Q: Can I switch between methods?
A: Yes, but requires uninstalling current method and clean installation of new one.

Q: Which has best Play Integrity bypass?
A: All struggle equally with modern attestation. Success depends on additional modules and device.

Q: Do all Magisk modules work on KernelSU?
A: About 80% compatibility. Check module documentation.

Q: Which method is safest?
A: All are safe when properly installed. KernelSU offers best architectural security.

Q: Will OTA updates work?
A: Only KernelSU sometimes survives OTA. Others require re-rooting.

Q: Battery impact?
A: Negligible for all methods. Module choice matters more.

---

Community Resources

Official Channels

• Magisk: GitHub|XDA|Telegram
• KernelSU: GitHub|Docs|Telegram
• APatch: GitHub|Telegram

General Support

• XDA Developers Forums
• r/AndroidRoot
• Device-specific Telegram groups

---

Final Recommendations

For 95% of Users

Start with Magisk - proven, documented, supported

For Power Users

Consider KernelSU if kernel available and security matters

For Edge Cases

Try APatch when standard methods fail

Universal Tips

1. Research device-specific quirks first
2. Maintain proper backups always
3. Test one module at a time
4. Join device-specific communities
5. Keep stock boot image handy

---

Next Steps

1. Choose your method based on this comparison
2. Follow installation guide:
   • Magisk Guide
   • KernelSU Guide
   • APatch Guide
3. Install essential apps: Root Apps Collection
4. Get support: Join relevant communities

---

Remember: The "best" method depends entirely on your specific device, technical comfort, and use case. When in doubt, start with Magisk.